Islamic Research Foundation International, Inc.
Seeking Advancement of Knowledge through Spiritual and Intellectual Growth

International ConferenceAbout IRFIIRFI CommitteesRamadan CalendarQur'anic InspirationsWith Your Help

Articles 1 - 1000 | Articles 1001-2000 | Articles 2001 - 3000 | Articles 3001 - 4000 | Articles 4001 - 5000 | Articles 5001 - 6000 |  All Articles

Family and Children | Hadith | Health | Hijab | Islam and Christianity | Islam and Medicine | Islamic Personalities | Other | Personal Growth | Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) | Qur'an | Ramadan | Science | Social Issues | Women in Islam |

Home
Islamic Articles
Islamic Links
Islamic Cemetery
Islamic Books
Women in Islam
Feedback
Aalim Newsletter
Date Conversion
Prayer Schedule
Scholarships
Q & A
Contact Info
Disclaimer
 

 

Palin & Hijab

Monday, September 15, 2008

When I first heard about the McCain campaignís protectiveness of Sarah Palin, and their cloaking her in mystery in response to the alleged lack of ďdeferenceĒ shown by the media, I thoughtóthis is crazy, sheís being swathed in hijab. Metaphorically.

I am no expert on Muslim culture, or the attire of Muslim women, but I recently read the fascinating novel Girls of Riyadh by Rajaa Alsanea. This is a book that has been called, albeit somewhat misleadingly, "Sex and the City" set in a major Saudi metropolis, and itís a window into the life of (seriously upper-class) young women in a nation that is governed strictly by Islamic doctrine. Whatís super-interesting is that despite what you would think, these girls are definitely body-image-obsessed fashionistas...Did you know that nowadays there are major high fashion designers creating hijab clothing? Awash in the sea of U.S.-generated anti-Arabic propaganda, I seriously had no idea about this. (For more info: high fashion hjiab). There are kind of two levels to this thing, one is the growing trend toward less traditional, more haute couture or hip hijab clothing, and the other is the fact that underneath the drape of an abaya over-garment, plenty of Muslim women are decked out in tank tops and jeans, minidresses and razor-sharp stilettos. Thatís because hijab only has to be worn outside the home and in the presence of non-family member males. So there are all these really important womenís spaces, where no men are present, where the abayas come off and the latest fashion trends are in full view. Itís these all-women spaces that really interest me.

There is a common perception among Americans and Europeans that women who wear hijab are oppressed and forced to do so. I live in a neighborhood that is home to many Pakistani and Bengali women who wear the veil, and there have been times, say in August, where Iíve seen women on the subway platform wearing what looks like a sweltering outfit, and it can be hard for me to understand the logic behind it all. But there are lots of Muslim women who say itís their choice to wear hijab (interesting to find the liberal feministsí preferred vocabulary in a way that seems to rub against the very tenets of liberal feminism...more on this below). I will say that the burqa (outfit with the veil that covers the entire face) is intense, and admittedly hard for me to relate to from an American perspective. But I think itís important not to extract one element of an entire society and demand that it change without taking into consideration that entire context and the role of women on a variety of levels within that society, in order to avoid just spouting stereotypic generalizations. Itís one thing to be mandated by law to wear a certain kind of clothing, and itís another to opt to wear it in a context where you will certainly stand out.

Some women who wear hijab, even outside the Arabic world, say that they feel freer in their loose-fitting clothing, they feel like they are safer from the judgments of others, especially male others, and that they feel more confident of being assessed for their intellect and behavior than for their appearance alone. From this perspective, trotting around all day in a bikini like those perkily interchangeable reality show girls we all have to endure is not a sign of freedom at all but is in fact its own form of oppression. Not to trivialize an experience that, for many, comes from a deep faith decision (It cannot be easy to wear hijab in the U.S. in these times. Come on.) but I imagine itís kind of like how I feel safer and more powerful when Iím wearing my sunglasses, and why Iím reluctant to put them away even though I know itís fall and I honestly donít need them anymore.

Another reason women cite for wearing the hijab is that it makes them recognizably Muslim. Itís an affirmation of spiritual and cultural identity. I can also imagine that one would feel seriously amazing identifying with the women who wear these gorgeous outfits.

So hereís the thing. At first I was raging: I canít believe this, they are cloaking Sarah Palin in this oppressive burqa, what kind of madness is this, how can they suggest that the American media viewership is lustful (ďnot-deferentialĒ) and that we all have to be protected from actually knowing this woman for our own good, yada yada...and doesnít that presume that the American public is male, is considering her from a male gaze anyways, and how jacked up is that?

But what this rage doesnít take into consideration is the fact that so many (white) American women are responding so strongly to Sarah Palin. There is a women-only community that she is invoking, even with her ďmodestyĒ in shielding herself from the presumed invasiveness of the media. Women look at her and think: ďI know her, her experience is similar to mine, we share the same space...sheís the quintessential working-class white woman: she popped out a baby and went back to work three days later, she is no-nonsense enough to juggle work and family life without complaining, she doesnít hold a Hillary-style Ivy League degree, she goes to church every Sunday and believes in the same God I do.Ē So that, even if the McCain campaign does presume a male gaze, what both they and the Democrats probably have not considered is the power encapsulated in these all-women spaces. These take-off-the-modest-clothing, chill-with-the-other-hockey-moms spaces. Just because conservative women donít embrace liberal feminism doesnít mean they donít understand themselves as defined by all-women spaces or sectors of the community. And it doesnít mean that they hesitate to appropriate feminist tactics when it comes to activism on behalf of conservative causes. It turns out I canít entirely blame those good old boys for secreting Sarah away and indoctrinating her into McBushRovian political strategy. She signed up for it herself, and Iím sure there are other women within the ďsafeĒ sphere of the McCain campaign community, like Nancy Pfotenhauer, former president of the conservative Independent Women's Forum and current senior policy adviser for that campaign, who are standing side-by-side with her in conservative feminist solidarity.

As political science scholar Ronnee Schreiber, author of Righting Feminism, points out: ďIt is a huge mistake to think of conservative women as pawns of right-wing men who will matter little in this election.Ē


More stuff on this topic:
Ronnee Schreiber on Palinís appeal to women
Rajaaa Alsanea (author of Girls of Riyadh) on Valentineís Day
All-women beach trends in Egypt
France denies citizenship to a burqa-wearing woman

impolitic_chick

 

 

http://impolitic-chick.blogspot.com/2008/09/palin-hijab-conservative-womens-spaces.html

Please report any broken links to Webmaster
Copyright © 1988-2012 irfi.org. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer
   

free web tracker