Empty Pockets, Angry Minds
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
Thomas L. Friedman is a New York Times Op-Ed Columnist.
I have no doubt that the Danish cartoons mocking the Prophet
Muhammad have caused real offense to many Muslims. I'm glad my
newspaper didn't publish them. But there is something in the
worldwide Muslim reaction to these cartoons that is excessive, and
suggests that something else is at work in this story. It's time we
talked about it.
To understand this Danish affair, you can't just read Samuel
Huntington's classic, "The Clash of Civilizations." You also need to
read Karl Marx, because this explosion of Muslim rage is not just
about some Western insult. It's also about an Eastern failure. It is
about the failure of many Muslim countries to build economies that
prepare young people for modernity — and all the insult, humiliation
and frustration that has produced.
Today's world has become so wired together, so flattened, that you
can't avoid seeing just where you stand on the planet — just where
the caravan is and just how far ahead or behind you are. In this
flat world you get your humiliation fiber-optically, at 56K or via
broadband, whether you're in the Muslim suburbs of Paris or Kabul.
Today, Muslim youth are enraged by cartoons in Denmark. Earlier, it
was a Newsweek story about a desecrated Koran. Why? When you're
already feeling left behind, even the tiniest insult from afar goes
to the very core of your being — because your skin is so thin.
India is the second-largest Muslim country in the world, but the
cartoon protests here, unlike those in Pakistan, have been largely
peaceful. One reason for the difference is surely that Indian
Muslims are empowered and live in a flourishing democracy. India's
richest man is a Muslim software entrepreneur. But so many young
Arabs and Muslims live in nations that have deprived them of any
chance to realize their full potential.
The Middle East Media Research Institute, called Memri, just
published an analysis of the latest employment figures issued by the
U.N.'s International Labor Office. The I.L.O. study, Memri reported,
found that "the Middle East and North Africa stand out as the region
with the highest rate of unemployment in the world": 13.2 percent.
That is worse than in sub-Saharan Africa.
While G.D.P. in the Middle East-North Africa region registered an
annual increase of 5.5 percent from 1993 to 2003, productivity, the
measure of how efficiently these resources were used, increased by
only about 0.1 percent annually — better than only one region,
The Arab world is the only area in the world where productivity did
not increase with G.D.P. growth. That's because so much of the G.D.P.
growth in this region was driven by oil revenues, not by educating
workers to do new things with new technologies.
Nearly 60 percent of the Arab world is under the age of 25. With
limited job growth to absorb them, the I.L.O. estimates, the region
is spinning out about 500,000 more unemployed people each year. At a
time when India and China are focused on getting their children to
be more scientific, innovative thinkers, educational standards in
much of the Muslim world — particularly when it comes to science and
critical inquiry — are not keeping pace.
Pervez Hoodbhoy, a professor of nuclear physics at Quaid-i-Azam
University in Islamabad, Pakistan, bluntly wrote the following in
Global Agenda 2006, the journal of the recent Davos World Economic
"Pakistan's public (and all but a handful of private) universities
are intellectual rubble, their degrees of little consequence. ...
According to the Pakistan Council for Science and Technology,
Pakistanis have succeeded in registering only eight patents
internationally in 57 years. ...
"[Today] you seldom encounter a Muslim name in scientific journals.
Muslim contributions to pure and applied science — measured in terms
of discoveries, publications, patents and processes — are marginal.
... The harsh truth is that science and Islam parted ways many
centuries ago. In a nutshell, the Muslim experience consists of a
golden age of science from the ninth to the 14th centuries,
subsequent collapse, modest rebirth in the 19th century, and a
profound reversal from science and modernity, beginning in the last
decades of the 20th century. This reversal appears, if anything, to
be gaining speed."
No wonder so many young people in this part of the world are
unprepared, and therefore easily enraged, as they encounter
modernity. And no wonder backward religious leaders and dictators in
places like Syria and Iran — who have miserably failed their youth —
are so quick to turn their young people's anger against an insulting
cartoon and away from themselves and the rot they have wrought.
Courtesy: New York Times, February 22, 2006