Women in Hell Hadith – Fabricated Hadith
Someone on another site posted this hadith. I have never heard of it before, so could anyone tell me if its an authentic hadith or a fabricated or weak hadith?
Imam Ali ibna Abu Thalib and Hadrat Fatimah once visited the Prophet SAW and found him in tears. They asked him the cause and he replied: "O Ali, on the night of my ascension (Miraj) I saw women of my ummah who were being severely punished that I became concerned for them and started crying. I saw a woman who had been hung by her breast. Then I saw a second woman who was eating her own flesh and fire raged below her. A third woman was hanging by her tongue and boiling water was being poured down her throat. A fourth was bent over, her hands and feet were tied together, and snakes and scorpions were crawling all over her. A fifth was deaf, dumb, and blind, enclosed in a cage of fire, her brain oozing out of the holes in her skull. Her body fell apart due to leprosy. Another was hung by her feet, inside and over. Yet another woman's body was being shredded to pieces by scissors made of fire. One woman had head of a pig and a body of a donkey and was given several punishments. Another had the face f a dog, fire was entering her body from her posterior and come out of her mouth and the angels were beating her with iron rods." Fatimah then inquired her father, "Please, tell me, what did these women do (to deserve such punishment)?" Then the Prophet SAW said: "Listen my dear; The one who was hanging by her breast used to deny her husband, his rightful pleasure; The one hanging by her feet used to go out of her house without her husband's permission; The one eating her own flesh used to beautify herself and show her body to man other than her husband; The one who's hands and feet are tied together and covered with snakes and scorpions never to care impurity and wasn't careful about ghusl, thus taking her prayer lightly; The deaf, blind, and dumb, used to bear children through adultery but claim the children belonged to her husband; the one whose body was being cut by scissors made of fire never observed hijab in front of non mahrem men. The one whose body was burned and who was eating her own intestines used to provide other woman for sex; the one with the face of a pig and a body of a donkey was a back bitter and a liar. And those with the face of a dog and who had fire entering her behind and coming out of her face was a jealous woman."
70:28 Lo! the doom of their Lord is that before which none can feel secure
Did they give a citation some of the things mentioned sound familiar, but tbh, it looks like they've "cross-bred" between texts to come up with some type of anti-Islamic baloney. you'll find that alot with "anti-Islam" people.
Arabic version of Women in Hell Hadith:
الامام علي بن
أبي طالب قال : دخلت أنا و
رسول الله صلى
الله عليه سلم
فوجدته يبكي بكاء
فداك أبي و
أمي يا رسول
الله ما الذي
صلى الله عليه
و سلم: يا علي
ليلة أسري بي
إلى السماء رأيت نساء
من أمتي في
عذاب شديد و
لما رأيت من
This is the original full version of the hadith you mentioned. It is Mawdoo and Monkar (Proven to be fabricated and denied), as in has no correctness whatsoever. It should not be mentioned except to warn people against it.
Iblis's eternal destination in the Hellfire is due to Arrogance, not Disbelief.
Please report any
broken links to
Copyright © 1988-2012 irfi.org. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer